Recently there has been a video on You Tube about current Muslim demographics that point to the decline of Christian culture. It has had over nine million viewers on You Tube, and its aim is to “wake up” Christians to the reality of the world around them and to challenge Christians to take steps to share the Gospel.
Fortunately, several commentators have already helped to point out the errors of this video. To me, the film is unfortunate because it not only misrepresents the situation, but because it mainly seeks to justify the xenophobia in people that readily blames the immigrant for society’s decline. I think it creates a motivation for engaging the culture around us that is rooted in fear and protectionism. I don’t think this is ultimately a very helpful or viable reason to take action as Christians.
The video concludes that our society will change due to Islamic immigration coupled with the high birth rate of Islamic families. This is only one side of the equation. Our culture has changed even without the influx of Islamic immigration. There has always been some aspect that is changing the world we live in -whether this has been through exploration and discovery, politics, immigration or technology. Check out another video on you tube about the changing world.
These films raise the question of what it all means for us today? but I think we should also ask what the Western values, ideals and agendas are that have led to the place we are. Maybe change would be good. Maybe it is time to face and reckon with the course of self-destruction that western culture has been on.
The video refers to the alarm that western states like Germany and France themselves raise at the prospect of growing muslim populations. The implication is that Christians would no longer have a political culture and society that is their own. Yet isn’t this the case now?
Western society would be unrecognizeable in an Islamic state, and Christians might be discriminated against. However, while this seems like a difficult and dangerous situation –at the risk of historical error– wouldn’t this be more like the world that existed at the start of the Christian age -before Constantine tied government and religion together? Didn’t the church once grow and thrive in a world that was not “Christian”, and depending on the time, in a world that was outright hostile and violent towards Christians.
I would question the understanding of faith that is so tied and limited to a single culture. Instead, I would argue that the spiritual health of Christians in this world has more to do with the level of trust that we live by and dependence on God that we demonstrate.
Migration has been part of human history since the Garden of Eden, and the scriptures give witness to God’s use of migration, particularly forced migration, to accomplish his plan in this world. Many immigrants today are forced migrants, whose story and journey will lead them to a new identity in Christ. As migrants they bring new ways of living, but they will also potentially bring the roots of a new and renewed Church.
These immigrant Christians are witnesses to the fact that to be Christian is not tied to a particular culture -neither the current western one or some Islamic culture that might be forced on someone. Rather Christian faith for them is found in a new identity with Christ. To me the current demographics are a helpful reminder that it is not our culture that makes us Christian. Instead being a Christian is about the transformation of identity that happens when one embraces the Gospel.
The call to me when I consider these demographics is not to reverse the trend somehow by rolling back time or by converting ones different from me. Rather the call is to embrace and to trust that God is still in control even when the odds might be stacked against me, and to promote faithfulness among those who identify themselves with Christ. The former call takes an anthropological view of the world, that emphasizes all that humans do to control and shape the world, while the latter call takes a Christological view that places God in the center as creator and provider who still, in spite of a world gone off course, will remain intimately active in transforming hopeless situations.

